Signers’ Comments

Signers’ Comments

What signers of the petition to UNESCO are saying. Please give us your comments.

John Ungvarsky I’m Catholic. I agree with this petition.

Marshall Kramer The petition says it all!

David Gutmann This is a well-mannered continuation of the Holocaust, based on this faulty logical sequence: “The jews are dead. Ergo , the Jews never existed. Ergo, all holy sites of Palestine must have had non-Jewish, Islamic origins.”

Richard Wolfert It is so sad that UNESCO has become a political arm for extremist views. It should return to its public mandate rather than acting in concert with such an embarrassing folly. There was a time when UNESCO actually performed with logic, and did good deeds. 

Christopher Smith It is outrageous, you would actually be denying Christianity by denying Judaism! You are busy destroying morality, ethics and truth! Think hard before you go ahead with your destruction and lies as all acts have consequences. Do not try to rub out Jewish history as that will rub out Christianity.

Rabbi Mark Bisman All holy spots were named by Constantine’s mother Catherine in 3rd century CE before Islam was born.

Sandor and Bunny Shuch Islam is only 1400 years old. Judaism is 4.000 years old, How can an Islamic Mosque predate a 4,000 year old Jewish burial site? 

 Shirley Kushner When will all this hatred end? You can hardly find Israel on the map amongst all its neighbourson thehe map amongst all its neighbours. I truly hope there will be PEACE in our lifetime or at least in our children’s lifetime. How much more do you want to rob from the Jews from their History & Heritage, which is thousands of years old? Without Love and Peace in your hearts, we will never be able to live together peacefully.

Harvey S. Jacobs Next on the mosque hit list as world heritage sites are, the Kremlin, St. Pauls Cathedral, London, Notre Dame, Paris, St. Patricks Cathedral, New York, the Shwe Dagon Pagoda, Mt. Fuji, the Easter Island Heads, Beijings Forbidden City the Parthenon. News flash the Hagia Sofia has also been declared a mosque. Rachels, Tomb, the cave of Machpela and Temple Mount predate Islam by up to 3500 years as Jewish Heritage sites, unless of course, there has been a mixup and the Ka’aba in Mecca has been designated a Jewish, or Christian or Hindu or Buddhist World Heritage site.